Sunday, September 16, 2007

Taking Reality Seriously

DOWN IN the comments on one of my previous posts, commenter JH was defending the virtues of Reality TV. Interestingly enough, in that "I love my commenters and I love the internet" kind of way, Caryn James picks up that very baton in today's New York Times, pointing to two new fictional works that move beyond our culture's recent "tut-tut" or "society is crumbling" view of the genre. Has it really only been seven years since the first Survivor? That means I'm barely 1/1000th through the half life of the image of Richard Hatch's naked ass burned on my retina. Bummer.

In her article, "Imaginary Trips Beyond Reality," James writes:

But now the form has become such a fixture of cultural life that a smarter, post-reality-television generation of novels and movies is beginning to emerge. The clever little film “Great World of Sound” (which opened on Friday) and the graphic novel “The Homeless Channel” (published in May) tackle the issues behind reality television with subtlety and a true understanding of the genre’s appeal. And even movies like last year’s satire “American Dreamz” and the current fantasy “The Nines,” which don’t go far in analyzing the genre, appreciate its allure.

That acceptance is significantly new. Before reality television became a cultural force, prescient movies from the late 1990s like “‘The Truman Show” and “Edtv” sounded an Orwellian alarm, forecasting a world in which a person’s entire life might be televised. When that actually happened, books and movies continued the easy path of sneering at the trend, in smug works that deserved their obscurity...But “Great World of Sound” and “The Homeless Channel” are informed by the knowledge that reality television is popular for a reason: Viewers become emotionally invested in the players, even if they disapprove of them for playing. And these works convey the queasiness that is the essence of the genre: the voyeuristic attraction and sense of unease on the part of the audience and the complicity of the contestants themselves.
Besides plugging John August's new film, "The Nines", James also gives a shout out to one of my favorite films about TV:

Reality television has so rapidly broadened — to encompass everything from the Machiavellian deceit of “Survivor” to the bone-headed guesses about which briefcase has the money in “Deal or No Deal” — it’s a wonder that it took this long for a postmodern twist to occur, especially since one of the most accomplished films about the genre was one of the earliest.

“Series 7: The Contenders,” from 2001, takes the shape of a reality show in which contestants track down and kill their opponents. From its shot-on-video look to the stentorian announcer’s voice that says, “Real people. Real danger,” the mock film is less a satire than a shadow version of a reality show that is also a devastating comment on it. And “Series 7” effectively taps into its viewers’ emotional investment in the players: a pregnant woman, an unemployed father, a gun-toting lunatic. Daniel Minahan, the film’s writer and director, gets television so well that he has since become a top director on shows like ‘Grey’s Anatomy.”

Far from being reflexively anti-reality TV, like many of my compatriots in the scripted arena, I've always maintained a healthy interest, if not utter engagement, with the form. It helps, I guess, that once upon a time I was a TV producer, so I've got that professional appreciation for the level of craft involved.

When it comes to the shows themselves, though, I have to admit my viewership was limited to the first few series of Survivor (they lost me in Africa, and got me back, briefly, for the one with Rupert and the All-Star Edition.) I feel like I would probably like The Amazing Race if I watched it, but not enough to commit to doing so. I did have brief and dirty flings with Rock Star: INXS, and Hell's Kitchen last summer, but I think that's probably just cause watching Gordon Ramsay shout at people is so sickly entertaining. I may be a bad person.

No, though I remember thinking right away, back in that first season of Survivor, that I was humbled by how well produced and well-edited it was, the main thing I thank reality TV for is its absolutely crystal-clear commitment to defining character. I think it's sharpened all of us -- those who cast for types, and those of us who try to create our characters out of whole cloth.

Canadian Reality TV never quite goes far enough -- not enough pre-research, not enough time shooting, not enough time to cut...but, like James, I'm glad that other forms have at least let go of the reflexive reality-bash to start seriously considering how the format has changed us, and the way we think about story.

For we all think about story: whether you're a writer or not. And I think if you're writing something and your character isn't as interesting as any bloke you'd see on a reality show -- then, my friend, I would hope you'd take that as your "Come to Jesus" moment.*

*Your "Come To Jesus" moment may not actually contain Jesus.

15 comments:

Unknown said...

Alas, I have flunked Reality TV Appreciation 101 on several attempts. I keep thinking "That could be cool to watch." And then, sure enough, I want to strangle everyone by about twenty minutes in.

I keep hoping, with the flowering of the genre, somebody will change up the formula such that the editing isn't tailored specifically for viewers who want to want to strangle everyone, but so far no dice. Even Project Runway, which I'm entirely too much of a design geek to resist, frequently finds me yelling "screw the draaaahma, show me the WORK!" at my poor hapless TV.

Still and all, it also hasn't killed scripted drama the way some of us out here in TV-land (yes, I'm guilty) were grumping about a few years ago. I can roll my eyes at the promos for the latest orgy of public humiliation while catching up on, in all honesty, too many good scripted shows to comfortably keep track of.

I still scratch my head about the workings of a mind that finds such things so riveting, but that territory is nothing but pots and kettles as far as the eye can see. :-)

Unknown said...

Hey Denis -

Thanks for linking to the NYT story! I wanted to take a moment to invite your readers to check out the the first chapter to The Homeless Channel which I have posted over at my homepage. I'd recommend the book to anyone who, like me, is a fan of both Aaron Sorkin's scripted television and reality TV. I had a lot of fun putting the book together and I'd love to hear what some of your TV savvy readers think!

All the best,

Matt

ME said...

You aren't a bad person for loving Gordon Ramsey yelling at people. He's bloody entertaining. Wait til you see the next round of Hell's Kitchen from the UK ... he bailed and his mentor Marco Pierre White is taking over the show and his bio makes Gordon sound like a girl scout ... he apparently reduced Gordon to tears on a regular basis.

I like good reality tv as much as I do good drama. I don't like stuff that's just plain stupid (Pirate Master, hello) or just destructive for the sake of being mean (probably Temptation Island is the best example of this for me - intentionally breaking people up who were otherwise happy). Lately I'm like the positive stuff ... Fat March was kind of sweet. And I do like the Amazing Race, mostly because it tries to shed a little light on history and culture and encourages a lazy-boy bound American audience to actually leave the continent and experience the richness of the world.

Brent McKee said...

I am another lover of The Amazing Race in part because it takes Shakespeare's phrase "All the world's a stage and the people in it merely players" literally. The world is its stage. Moreover, it's not about public humiliation, it is what it says it is, a race around the world, a competition. The Amazing Race is the only reality show I would even consider applying for.

But of course I can't apply to be on it because I'm Canadian, which brings up a major point. There's no reason why Canadian networks can't do shows like Survivor, Dancing With The Stars, (America's) Got Talent (with a name change of course), or The Amazing Race. Other countries do. Dancing with the Stars is in at least a dozen other countries and the same is true of America's Got Talent. There's an Asian version of The Amazing Race getting ready to do a second season, and another one based out of Eastern Europe that is is preparation. Shows like this should be a natural, but so far the only one we've really seen is Canadian Idol and the only reason I can see for that is because Canadian networks can get the American versions cheaper so why make our own.

The_Lex said...

Oh. . .great! I guess that means my novel will be obsolete when I'm finally done with it. Especially tragic since I've been working on this version of it for three or four years. Argh!

Must work faster. . .must work faster. . ..

DMc said...

I'm continually amazed when Canadians seem perplexed that they can't apply to American reality shows.

Are you proud of the beer being stronger and want to be able to travel 'round Europe with the flag on your rucksack, or do you want to be Yankees so you can be on Yankee show?

Pick one, dudes. Pick one.

Diane Kristine Wild said...

Why do we have to pick one? That's like saying we have to pick one way to spell colo(u)r. Or need to watch Guy Maddin films instead of Wes Anderson films. Canadians can apply to some American reality shows ... just not the good ones.

Jeff Heywood said...

Brent, I think the reason there are not many Global, CTV, etc Canadian reality shows is exactly what you said...money.

Canadian reality of the native kind lives mostly on HGTV and Slice (good lord what an awful name). Shows like Crash Test Mommy and the like. Those shows are easy to crank. 2.5 days shooting per episode, crew of 10 or so and 3-4 weeks of editing and there you go.

The biggest mostly Canadian productions have to be Making the Cut (season one was averaging about 700k viewers) and No Boundaries back in 2000. Those are two shows that hadn't really been done anywhere else (NB was a Norwegian original I think). They were huge by Canuck standards. NB was a co-pro with WB in the US and mostly supported by Ford whose vehicles were featured prominently. Unfortunately WB dumped it after 2 shows because of regime change at the network and 9/11 which apparently created a nation that was kinder and gentler and non-reality friendly.

Making the Cut bought air time then got it's revenue from selling ads in the block and product placement. CBC didn't really spend anything.

Season 2 of Making the Cut got left in the backwaters of the schedule, probably for the simsub reasons outlined in a previous post. Global gets their cancon and don't have to risk other ratings.

For what it is worth, No Boundaries was a show that was ahead of its time and was phenomenal for what it did and the stories it told. It was also amazing for the fact no one died, and no one was lost. There were 60 crew in the backwoods from Victoria to the Arctic Circle over the course of four weeks. It was a grind beyond a grind. In the woods, dirty, covered in mosquitos, back-pack full of energy bars and tons of water, because you don't really know how long it will be before someone comes to get you.
There really was no time off, there was sleep and there was work, sometime there was sleep at work in a tent while you waited for something to happen, if something happened, there was no sleep.

DMc said...

It's weird because Canadians have a permeable vision of their place vis a vis the United States.

I would think most of the people who would be upset that Canadians can't apply would understand why, say, Italians aren't eligible for a show on American network TV.

But not us...we's special.

Diane Kristine Wild said...

Really? I didn't hear that at all. I heard an individual wishing he could be on a cool show and, barring being allowed to be on the US version, having a Canadian version.

If a show like On the Lot and Last Comic Standing can let both Canadians and Italians participate, it's not like the Amazing Race can't - though of course it's their prerogative to keep it US only.

And Canadians are special - we get the shows at the same time as the US, while Italians don't. A point you've made several times over for why the Canadian TV is screwed - we're effectively part of the same market as US TV. Talk about permeable visions.

DMc said...

Hey Diane,

Sspssssfffaffftllltltttt!

DMc said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Diane Kristine Wild said...

That's mature. Typical American ;)

Diane Kristine Wild said...

You get that I was poking you for taking any excuse to make a completely a propos of nothing generalization denigrating all Canadians, right? Using an example that made equally little sense?

Yeah. Never mind. You obviously haven't heard that Canadians are a funny people.

DMc said...

Poor Canadian. Always trying to explain yourself. It's okay. We get it. You're worthy. Very world class.