BELOW, COMMENTER "J-POD" (yes, I know that's a little confusing) wanted to talk SOPHIE, specifically, what he/she thought was missing in the translation from the Québécois original, "Les hauts et les bas de Sophie Paqin" (The Ups and Downs of Sophie Paqin):And if you're thinking that I cynically promoted this comment just to have another chance to run a picture of the lovely Natalie Brown, well, you're only partly right, there, Smuggy McSmugson.
"Reducing the golden source material from one hour format to a condensed half killed the joy that the original French version had. "Les hauts et les bas de Sophie Paqin" ... has smarter casting in that the token gay best friend was immediately given depth and purpose and Estelle's [the remaining client played by Sara Botsford in the remake] character was unadultarated fun and over the top with her artificial Parisian accent and her regalesque sense of entitlement. The addition of a few more scenes eased the viewer into the story; introducing Sophie's frost-biting mother and deadbeat brother provided the series with a sense of continuation and ultimate purpose. "Sophie" missed the beat by making the title character a little more slapstick than her Québécois counterpart. And to answer your question, yes, seeing the black baby was funny -- after an hour of buildup.Ah, the perils of adaptation. Do it right and you've got All in the Family. Do it wrong, you've got the American Coupling, or Cracker.
I was disappointed with this outing and with the decision to make this series a half-hour comedy. I guess I was spoiled by the original.
What I find immediately interesting about the above comment was the example of Estelle. I believe in one of the reviews I read it mentioned this character who talked in an English accent for no good reason. But if you look at the above, you can see the cultural translation.
For a Quebec audience, a person speaking French with a faux Parisian accent means something very, very key. It suggests putting on airs, an unearned sense of cultural superiority. It's a rich character detail.
Lost in Translation.
It's tricky, boy.
I confess to not worrying too much about the black baby at the end, and being eager to see the relationship between Mother and Daughter. I do think, to be fair, the English SOPHIE needs to be given a few weeks to find its feet. Remember, in the beginning even adaptations that people consider great -- like the U.S. translation of The Office, take a while to find their way. U.S. Showrunner Greg Daniels admitted as much to me when I talked to him in Banff.
I don't know if Sophie Parker will ever hold a similar place in the hearts of TROC (The Rest of Canada) as Sophie Paqin does to the Quebec audience. But I do know this: the premiere got 636 000 viewers in Canada -- which means it kept 80% of its lead in from Little Mosque on the Prairie. That's not bad.
Maybe Sophie will grow on us. I hope so.
Of course, next week she & Mosque go up against a little show called, Idol something or other...












